Tuesday, April 19, 2011

WATER FOR ELEPHANTS by Sara Gruen


THE GIST:

A young man joins the circus and finds himself in a menagerie of trouble.

THE VERDICT:

This engaging story provides a unique snapshot of a fantastic and unusual sort of life. Gruen creates a singular portrait of the secret world of a traveling circus, but also of Depression-era American life. It's a romantic and desperate tale about what people do when they have nowhere else to go.

I was not quite as impressed with the book as I wanted to be after hearing so much about it, but I still enjoyed reading it. Some of the dialogue seemed loosely drawn and I wanted to see a bit more complexity in the characters. Rosie the elephant was the character who grew the most over the course of the book, and she was easily my favorite. I would have liked to hear more details about the performers and the working men and the book could easily have been a bit longer.

The story is framed by the recollections of a man in his 90s. This device allows the story to be sweet and sad as well as exciting and romantic. The depiction of Jacob as a very old man was very well done, and I was definitely rooting for him at the end. I would recommend this book as a flat out enjoyable read, even though it leaves you wanting more.

THE LINK:

Sara Gruen's website, including information about the upcoming film

THE COST:

Currently listed at $4.00 for the Kindle edition, though I think I paid $6.00 last week

THE QUESTION:

What are some other good stories that are told as memories and flashbacks? How does the frame affect your reading of the story?

3 comments:

  1. I liked this book as well. I'm going to publish my review tomorrow (even though I read it 2-3 years ago).

    What?
    Capitalizing on the movie for a cheap promotion of my blog?

    How dare you!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've read lots of reviews of this book - but I like your straightforward approach to it. I still want to read it, but perhaps with slightly lowered expectations - often not a bad thing!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes, I definitely enjoyed it, even if it wasn't the best novel ever. I was pleased to see that the movie is coming out so soon. There's a two week delay before it gets to HK, but I'm still looking forward to it.

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...